America’s Spy Software Scandal,
Courtesy of the U.S. DOJ
By Michelle Malkin
July 16, 2003
Montgomery County, PA Vol. XXIV, NO. 9
Summary: Inslaw deserves to be compensated. More importantly, the American people deserve to know the truth: Did government greed and bureaucratic hubris lead to a wholesale sellout of our national security? Did Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden have access to a U.S. computer tracking program that enabled them to monitor our intelligence-gathering efforts and financial transactions? If so, who is responsible for allowing the program to fall into their hands? And who else among America’s enemies might have access to the tracking system?
It’s an explosive spy software scandal that no one in official Washington wants to investigate.
This complex, tangled story began two decades ago, when a tiny private company called Inslaw Inc. developed a software package to help U.S. attorneys’ offices in large urban districts keep tabs on their criminal prosecutors’ caseloads. The program, dubbed the Prosecutor’s Management Information System (PROMIS), was effective and popular. It allowed a prosecutor to locate defendants and witnesses, track motions and monitor ongoing investigations. In 1982, Inslaw won a large Justice Department contract to implement the system nationwide.
In the meantime, Inslaw also developed privately owned enhancements to PROMIS. Despite contractural guarantees of Inslaw’s proprietary rights to the enhanced version of PROMIS, the Justice Department essentially commandeered the improved program for its own uses without paying for it. Inslaw was forced into bankruptcy and began an endless fight with the Justice Department to recoup its losses.
In the course of their court battles, Inslaw founder Bill Hamilton and his wife innocently stumbled upon shocking national security revelations. Former Attorney General Ed Meese, the Hamiltons concluded, had conspired to force Inslaw into bankruptcy so that an old Meese crony, California businessman Earl Brian, could take over the company’s assets. The Hamilton’s obtained information through sworn affidavits of several individuals that suggested Meese, Brian, high-ranking Justice Department official Peter Videnieke and others wanted to modify and distribute the enhanced PROMIS software with ‘back-door’ capabilities for covert intelligence operations.
In 1987, a federal judge blasted the Justice Department for stealing PROMIS. The government, Judge George Bason said, stole Inslaw’s software through “trickery, fraud, and deceit” with contempt for both the law and any principle of fair dealing.” The House Judiciary Committee also found in 1992 that there was “strong evidence” the Justice Department had conspired to steal the PROMIS program. An internal Justice Department memo made public by the committee revealed that the Justice Department had secretly turned over a copy of PROMIS to the Israeli government.
An extensive four-part series by Insight magazine reporter Kelly Patricia O’Meara retraced a lengthy investigation by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police two years ago, which “uncovered a network involving friend and foe alike that may be using PROMIS and systems like it for a variety of illegal activities worldwide.”
In June 2001, Jerry Seper of the Washington Times reported that former FBI agent and convicted spy Robert Hanssen sold an enhanced version of PROMIS for $2 million to Russian crime figures, who in turn are suspected of selling a black-market version of it to Osama bin Laden.
More recently, the International Currency Review, a London-based financial newsletter , reportedly obtained Iraqi intelligence documents alleging that PROMIS came into Saddam Hussein’s possission under the Bush I administrations. The publication’s editor says the documents were owned by Hussein’s half-brother, Barzan al Takritil
And last week, British news outlets suggested that the resignation of top Bush terrorism intelligence official Paul Redmond was tied to his investigation of Hanssen and the PROMIS theft. The Department of Homeland Security claims that Redmond, a legendary spy catcher who came out off retirement to take the Bush administration position and had served only three months, left for “health reason.”
The odor of a cover-up is unmistakable. To this day, the Justice Department, FBI and other government agencies continue to insist that they have never possessed or used any pirated version of PROMIS. Career Justice officials who oversaw the theft of the Hamilton’s software program in the 1980’s remain in place today. And according to my sources, the 9-11 Commission created by President Bush had declined to investigate this spy software fiasco and its possible role in facilitating the terrorist attacks on America.
Inslaw deserves to be compensated. More importantly, the American people deserve to know the truth: Did government greed and bureaucratic hubris lead to a wholesale sellout of our national security? The Bush White House’s credibility is on the line.
Malkin is a graduate of Oberlin College in Oberlin, Ohio. She lives with her husband in North Bethesda, Md.